Monday, February 27, 2012

How did Ramananda Sagar show this scene in his TV Serial?


Volume 1 - Adi Parva. Chapter 136. Verse 005 to 010.
|| atha dAnApadESEna kuntI brahmaNabhojanam-

cakrE niSi mahad rAjann Ajagmus tatra yoshitah

tA vihritya yathAkAmam bhuktvA pItvA ca bhArata-

jagmur niSi grihAn Eva samanugnApya mAdhavIm

|| nishAdI pancaputrA tu tasmin bhojyE yadricchayA-

annArthinI samabhyAgAt saputrA kAlacoditA

|| sA pItvA madirAm mattA saputrA madavihvalA-

saha sarvaih sutai rAjams tasminn Eva nivESanE

||E sushvApa vigatagnAnA mritakalpA narAdhipa

|| atha pravAtE tumulE niSi suptE janE vibho-

tad upAdIpayad Bhimah SEtE yatra purocanah

tatah pratApah sumahAJ SabdaS caiva vibhAvasoh-

prAdurAsIt tadA tEna bubudhE sa janavrajah



CONTEXT and GIST
Dhritarashtra and Duryodhana sent Pandavas to the city VaraNAvata and made them to lodge in a house made of lac, clarified butter and inflammable materials. Their plan was to kill the Pandavas in a fire.

Minister Vidura, a well-wisher of Pandavas cautioned them about the impending danger and sent a miner to dig a tunnel in the house, to enable the Pandavas to escape.

Pandavas spent one year in the city in a convincing manner so that Duryodhana's employee purOcana did not suspect them that they were aware of the plan.

The appointed day having arrived, Kunti gave a party to Brahmin women. Among the women who ate and drank freely, there was a nishAdini (woman of a hunter/tribal) caste with five sons.

Before Duryodhana's employee purOcana executed his plan of igniting the house of lac, the second of the Pandavas-- bhIma set fire to the house of lac and carried his mother and brothers out to safety.

Among the dead was the nishAdI woman with her five sons who were lying their fully drunk.

(People thought that the dead woman was Kunti and the five sons were Pandavas).


ybrems
This can't be by accident or coincidence. This seems to be a deliberate act of Pandavas.
Reason for this deduction: If the house does not contain the dead bodies of woman and five youth, Duryodhana and Dhritarashtra might not have believed that Pandavas were dead. D and D, would have suspected that Pandavas escaped into the wild. Kauravas would have sent armies of men to search for the escaping targets.

Obviously, Pandavas tried to create a fake evidence of their own death. Ok, that was justifiable, considering that their lives were in danger. But why should they select a lowly nishAdi woman for their act? Were nishada lives cheaper than Brahmin lives or kshatriya (fighter-caste) lives? Were Pandavas afraid that Priests would curse them, if a woman of their caste and her five sons were killed?

ybrem--2
The general impression among Indians is that, it was Krishna who helped Pandavas, by advising Bhima to dig the tunnel. Indians believe that it was Bhima who dug the trench day and night, single-handedly. Very few Indians know that it was the miner sent by Vidura who did the digging work. In my mother tongue Telugu, we have a Telugu film by name 'Sri Krishna PAnDAvIyam' by late N.T. Rama Rao, which had a song 'mattu vadalara! (Wake up, leave the lethargy). Krishna advised Bhima in the song, to do his duty. The song is very sweet, appealing and didactic. But it is obvious that NTR changed the story. Telugu people believe that NTR made good researches on stories and scripts of his mythological films.

Interpreting or understanding mythology from what is shown in films or TV serials is risky in the sense that it does not help in exploration of truth.


How did Ramananda Sagar show this story in his TV Serial?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Severe Criticism is also welcome. Email for private communications with your personal address. specificpurp. It is at gmail.com.

Are you searching for objective type Multiple Choice Questions in any subject?

Are you searching for Objective Type Multiple Choice Questions on various subjects, to prepare for various Admission Tests and Competitive Exams? Here is a free site from ybrao. Online answering and evaluation of random-generated question papers are available free. No charges for anything.


World-level or global level:
http://ayyo.zxq.net.




Only India-related:
http://ayyoi.zxq.net.

Search Mahabharata (English-Ganguli translation) upto 5 words



click


ayyo.zxq.net/maha.php.

ayyo.zxq.net/mahaeg812.php Drona Parva to Shanti Parva.

Bombay version.

spelling variations.


tips for search 1.


tips 2

You can give upto 5 words to search. If you give only one or two words you will get large number of results, making it difficult to study.

Search upto 5 words in Vyasa Mahabharata Sanskrit Verses


Click.
ayyoi.zxq.net/mahas.php (Sanskrit).





Suggestions: Change/vary spellings if you do not expected result. Spellings used in the roman script of mahabharata uploaded by me, may differ from your spelling. Thanks for taking the trouble..